We’re getting Dear Husband Edgar’d again.
Had to look up that reference! I debated whether or not to post this link because I kind of feel like, yes, we’ve heard this all before, what you’re saying isn’t new and isn’t really true because the Internet very much still has places. But then I thought I may just be crotchety and there are plenty of people who don’t realize that so maybe someone will get some value from reading it.
funnily enough, i just wrote about how the Internet is a place:
This nostalgic romanticization is common and understandable, but the Internet is always going to be a place, for better or for worse.
Back when the way to get online was by going to an internet cafe, the internet definitely was a place. Arguably not so much anymore, but it used to be a thing. In living memory, even.
I wondered if the post was from someone who just wasn’t clued in, so I checked the About page and got distracted with trying to figure out if the images looked machine generated. Then I navigated to the home page and noticed blogpost titles like these:
- What Happened to Shareware?
- When Installing Software Meant Owning It
- Why Personal Websites Are Coming Back
- AI Slop Isn’t the Same Thing as AI-Assisted Work
- The Case for Owning Your Online Identity
- What We Lost When Websites Became Platforms
- Why RSS Never Really Died
So I figured, okay, I’m noticing some themes here. Overall this whole blog seems calculated to appeal to a certain-- Wait a second. Zoom in on that one:
AI Slop Isn’t the Same Thing as AI-Assisted Work
AI-assisted work is different when the human remains in charge. The person decides the subject, the argument, the evidence, the structure, the cuts, the final wording, and the point of publishing. The machine may help with research organization, alternate phrasing, rough outlines, summary, cleanup, or checking for blind spots. The author still has to know what is true, what is fair, what belongs, and what should be thrown away.
So… when a blogger starts talking like this, in combination with some questionable images, that leads me to wonder… how much of this is bot generated? Is this whole blog just a ploy?
I don’t know that it is, but in this case it’s difficult to find reassurances that it isn’t, and while I’m sympathetic to the reasons for sharing the link here, I’m thinking the possibility of bot-generated indie web bait is something worth watching out for. We’ve seen it happen before.
Fuck it, not this one too. goes through bookmarks and such Deleted, deleted, deleted.
I thought the domain name sounded familiar … clicked on the Mastodon link and realized it was an account I’d blocked previously for posting excessive AI slop to some hashtags I follow. The post that more or less confirmed it for me around the time when I blocked it was this one:
Whyyyyyyyyyy are LLMs so prone to overusing the adverb “quietly”? It makes my eyeballs twitch when I see it now.
Hah, what a curious situation. I added the feed to my newsreader yesterday and skim read a few of the posts, but nothing really jumped out as an interesting or new point of view.
Could it be a lost soul, just too deep into LinkedIn posts and YouTube thumbnails? But that’s still very jarring with the topics of the content.
To what end?
